HomeMy WebLinkAbout1982_06_23 Town Board Special Minutes 123
MINUTES OF A SPECIAL MEETING OF THE TOWN
BOARD OF THE TOWN OF MAMARONECK, HELD ON
THE 23RD DAY OF JUNE 1982 IN THE AUDITORIUM
OF THE WEAVER STREET FIREHOUSE, TOWN OF
MAMARONECK.
The Deputy Supervisor called the meeting to order at 8:00 P.M.
Present were the following:
Deputy Supervisor Lee H. Bloom
Councilman Steward J. McMillan
Councilman Thomas R. Amlicke
Councilwoman Caroline Silverstone
Supervisor Leo Goldsmith, Jr. was not in attendance at this meeting
due to illness.
Also present were the following:
Dorothy S. Miller, Town Clerk
James J. Johnston, Town Attorney
Charles R. Elfreich, Town Engineer
P. Thomas Leddy, Highway Superintendent
Also in attendance were the following members of the Town Planning
Board: Chairman Paul'.Kalos, Anton Schramm, Emil Nicolaysen, Mary
Carlson and Warner Pyne and the Secretary to that Board, Rita Johnson.
Deputy Supervisor Bloom at this time pointed out to those assembled
the location of the exits as required by law for public hearings.
At this time Deputy Supervisor Bloom reversed the order of the
agenda and took up the items under BOARD OF FIRE COMMISSIONERS
BOARD OF FIRE COMMISSIONERS
1. Claims
Commissioner Bloom presented fire claims for authorization of
payment and, on motion by Commissioner Silverstone, seconded by
Commissioner Amlicke, it was unanimously
RESOLVED, that this Commission hereby
authorizes payment of the following
Fire Department claims as approved by
the Fire Chief and audited by the
Comptroller's office:
-1-
•
1P4
AAA Emergency Supply Co. , Inc. $ 58.75
R. G. Brewer,Inc. 27.49
Brigante Lawnmower,Inc. 94.75
Frank Claps 200.00
Con Edison 34.77
Con Edison 2.00
Con Edison 3.00
Dri-Chem Extinguisher Co. 511.25
Excelsior Garage & Machine Works,Inc. 534.97
Exterminating Services Corp. 14.16
Fire Chiefs' Emergency Plan 75.00
Harbor Marine Canvas,Inc. 18.00
I & T Plumbing and Heating,Inc. 97.00
I & T Plumbing and Heating,Inc. 56.10
Larchmont Auto Parts Dist. , Inc. 7.71
N. LaRussell 398.76
Mid-Valley Petroleum Corp. 340.05
New York Telephone Co. 49.98
Signacon Controls,Inc. 160.00
Westchester Joint Water Works 62.01
$ 2,745.75
Not on Agenda
2. Reports
Commissioner Bloom presented the Fire Report for the month of May 1982.
ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business to come before this Commission, on
motion unanimously made and seconded, this meeting was declared ad-
journed at 8:05P.M.
Thereafter it was unanimously decided to take up the items in regular
order of the agenda, but hold the Joint Public Hearing last.
1. Resolution - Change Date of Next Regular Town Board Meeting
On Motion by Councilwoman Silverstone, seconded by Councilman Amlicke,
it was unanimously
RESOLVED, that this Board hereby
changes the date of the regular
meeting in July 1982 from July 7th
to July 14th.
2. Reappointment - Planning Board
Deputy Supervisor Bloom explained that Mrs. Carlson's term on the
Planning Board will expire prior to the next meeting, and Council-
woman Silverstone stated she was delighted to propose that Mary
Carlson,who has a degree from Yale and has been a City Planner,
-2-
125
be reappointed and thereafter, on her motion, which was seconded
by Councilman Amlicke, it was unanimously
RESOLVED, that Mrs. Mary Carlson of
17 North Chatsworth Avenue, Town, be
and she hereby is reappointed a member
of the Town of Mamaroneck Planning
Board, to serve for a 5-year term of
office effective July 7, 1982 and
terminating July 6, 1987.
3. Announcement - Town Administrator
Deputy Supervisor Bloom with great pleasure announced that the gentle-
man he was authorized to offer the position of Town Administrator to
had accepted at a salary of $28,000. He stated that Stephen V. Altieri
for five years has been an Administrative Assistant to Lowell Tooley,
the Manager in the Village of Scarsdale and has a Bachelors degree
and is working toward a Masters in Business Administration. He pre-
sently lives with his wife Deborah in Scarsdale in a Village owned
house and is now looking for a home in this area. Mr. Bloom added
that Mr. Altieri will begin work with the Town the day after Labor Day
and stated further that the job description has been forwarded to the
County Personnel Office and if it is necessary to adopt a local law
permitting Mr. Altieri to reside outside the community, that issue will
be taken up at a subsequent meeting. He stated that a great deal of
time has been spent on this matter and he was delighted to announce the
appointment of the Town's first Administrator.
Not on Agenda
1. Appointment to Committee to Study Alternative Structures of a
Police Commission
Councilwoman Silverstone proposed the name of John Herz to serve on the
above noted Committee and thereupon, on her motion which was seconded
by Councilman Amlicke, it was unanimously
RESOLVED, that John Herz be and he
hereby be appointed a member of the
Committee to Study Alternative
Structures of a Police Commission.
4. Pursuant to Deputy Supervisor Bloom's notation about the need
to hold an executive session, on motion by Councilwoman Silverstone,
seconded by Councilman Amlicke, it was by majority vote that the
following resolution was adopted:
RESOLVED, that this Board will convene for
an Executive Session immediately following
the adjournment of this meeting to discuss
litigation and the settlement thereof.
Councilman McMillan obstained from the vote and disqualified himself
from attendance at the session.
-3-
126
6. Resolution - Authorization of Joint Project A-897 - Installation
of 530 ft. of 12-inch Pipe on Macy Road, Town of Harrison
Following clarifying explanations by Deputy Supervisor Bloom and
Councilwoman Silverstone regarding the project, on motion by Council-
woman Silverstone, seconded by Councilman Amlicke, it was unanimously
RESOLVED, that as recommended by the Westchester
Joint Water Works, this Board hereby approves the
following joint project in accordance with the
agreement between Port Chester Water Works and
Westchester Joint Water Works for the estimated
cost of $45,000.00 to ultimately be paid in full
by Port Chester: Project A897 Installation of
530 feet of 12" pipe on Macy Road, Town of Harrison
at an estimated cost of $45,000.00 to be allocated
percentage wise among the three municipalities,
the Town's share being 21.6% or $9,720.00
7. Set Date for Public Hearing - Application for Special Permit -
Bonnie Briar Country Club - Proposed Extension to Pro Shop
On motion by Councilman Amlicke, Seconded by Councilwoman Silverstone,
it was unanimously
RESOLVED, that this Board hereby
sets July 14, 1982 as the date for
a public hearing on the application
for special permit so as to allow
construction of an addition to the
existing pro shop at the Bonnie Briar
Country Club;
and it is further
RESOLVED, that the Town Clerk be
and she hereby is authorized to
publish in The Daily Times, the
Notice of said hearing as required
by law.
8. Salary Authorizations - Recreation - Summer Programs
On motion by Councilman Amlicke, seconded by Councilman McMillan, it
was unanimously
RESOLVED, that as provided for in the
1982 Town Budget, this Board hereby
authorizes the following salary ex-
penditures to the persons named on the
list annexed hereto, for the terms of
employment and at the rate of compensa-
tion for each as set forth:
-4-
• d
i
127
!
MURRAY PRE SCHOOL
Mazzone, Nora Sr. Rec. Leader $120.00
1 Johnson, Helena Rec. Assistant $ 55.00
Johnson, Karen Rec. Assistant $ 42.00
Barbieri, Catherine Rec. Assistant $ 40.00
Coupe, Claire Rec. Assistant $ 38.00
Hartman, Beth Rec. Assistant $ 38.00
Hartman, Jennifer Rec. Assistant $ 38.00
1 Millar, Douglas Rec. Assistant $ 38.00
Neville, Sharon Rec. Assistant $ 38.00
O'Hara, Mary Rec. Assistant $ 38.00
HOMMOCKS POOL
LaMagna, Laura Head Lifeguard g g $ 4.25/hour
Bender, Edward Lifeguard $ 3.25/hour
Brenner, Anne Lifeguard $ 3.25/hour
Johanson, Philip Lifeguard $ 3.25/hour
Owen, Dawn Lifeguard $ 3.25/hour .
Quinlan, Maureen Lifeguard $ 3.25/hour
Reilly, Beth Lifeguard $ 3.25/hour
Reilly, Brad Lifeguard $ 3.25/hour
Zierk, Jon Lifeguard $ 3.25/hour
Irwin, Liz Rec. Attendant $ 2.75/hour
Macri, Beth Rec. Attendant $ 2.75/hour
Moore,Lucy Rec. Attendant $ 2.75/hour
Pampel, Joseph Rec. Attendant $ 2.75/hour
Treacy, Peter Rec. Attendant $ 2.75/hour
. Ferro, Cindy Sr. Rec. Leader $ 3.75/hour
Quinlan, Joanne Rec. Assistant $ 3.25/hour
CO-OP DAY CAMP
Franklin, Any Rec. Assistant $600.00 TOTAL. .
Mclvor, Kevin Rec. Assistant $500.00 TOTAL
Bluiett, William Rec. Assistant $400.00 TOTAL
Halliday, Linda Rec. Assistant $400.00 TOTAL '
Vaughn, Lynn Rec. Assistant $400.00 TOTAL
Mouracade, Mike Rec. Assistant $350.00 TOTAL
Zierk, Holly Rec. Assistant $350.00 TOTAL
Colangelo, Barb Rec. Assistant $350.00 TOTAL
Proudian, Greg Rec. Assistant $350.00 TOTAL
g $
Uelena, Julio Rec. Assistant $350.00 TOTAL
Regan, John Rec. Assistant $350.00 TOTAL
Chiodo, Geri Rec. Assistant $350.00 TOTAL
Martin, Kevin Rec. Assistant $350.00 TOTAL
Toten, Daren Rec. Assistant $350.00 TOTAL
Brown, Traci Rec. Assistant $350.00 TOTAL
Kaplan, Amy Rec. Assistant $350.00 TOTAL
CENTRAL PLAYGROUND
I Paterno, Philip Sr. Rec. Leader $200.00(8 weeks)
Chiapparelli, Michael Sr. Rec. Leader $200.00
Forbes, Susan Sr. Rec. Leader $ 80.00 (P.T.)
Perri, Dawn Rec. Assistant $ 80.00
Carr, John Rec. Assistant $ 74.00
Woods, Deborah Rec. Assistant $ 80.00
Irwin, Elizabeth Rec. Assistant $ 75.00
Medico, Leonard Rec. Assistant $ 75.00
Seiden, Linda Rec. Assistant $ 75.00
-5-
I
• 128
TENNIS INSTRUCTION
Rutledge, Suzanne Sr. Rec. Leader $ 175.00
Malfa, Laura Rec. Assistant $ 70.00
SAILING
Paolucci, John Rec. Assistant $ 4.00/hour
Bowne, Christopher Rec. Assistant $ 3.50/hour
Peet, Mimi Rec. Assistant $ 3.50/hour
Tomlin, Reid Rec. Assistant
er, Eric Rec. Assistant $ 3.50/hour
Weinber
g $ 3.50/hour
MUSIC WORKSHOP
Martin, Perry Sr. Rec. Leader $ 240.00 (5 weeks)
Seih, Eleanor Rec. Assistant $ 90.00 (5 weeks)
Friedman,James Rec. Assistant $ 65.00 (5 weeks)
Targove, Wendy Rec. Assistant $ 65.00 (5 weeks)
Williams, Richard Rec. Assistant $ 65.00 (5 weeks)
Green, Martin Rec. Assistant $ 65.00 (5 weeks)
Eldring, Suzanna Rec. Assistant $ 35.00 (5 weeks)
Melnick, Ken Rec. Assistant $ 35.00 (5 weeks)
Newman, Renee Rec. Assistant $ 30.00 (5 weeks)
FITNESS
Trezza, Jerry Sr. Rec. Leader $ 80.00
Chiapparelli, Michael Sr. Rec. Leader $ 40.00
BASKETBALL
Rella, Richard Sr. Rec. Leader $ 80.00
II/ CENTRAL PRE SCHOOL
Paterno, Bonnie Sr. Rec. Leader $ 100.00
O'Neill, Beth Rec. Assistant $ 40.00
O'Toole, Dennis Rec. Assistant $ 38.00
Sanchez, Lara Rec. Assistant $ 38.00
Wei, Jimmy Rec. Assistant $ 38.00
Woods, Patricia Rec. Assistant $ 38.00
CHATSWORTH PRE SCHOOL
Forbes, Susan Sr. Rec. Leader $ 100.00
Chiodo, Donna Rec. Assistant. $ 42.00
Vail, April Rec. Assistant $ 42.00
Adams, Karen Rec. Assistant $ 40.00
Brustman, Kathleen Rec. Assistant $ 38.00
Gunsalus, Curt Rec. Assistant $ 38.00
Long, Meghan Rec. Assistant $ 38.00
O'Toole, Kathleen Rec. Assistant $ 38.00
Schmeidler, Lynn Rec. Assistant $ 38.00
Tamagna, Kathy Joe Rec. Assistant $ 38.00
Not on Agenda
1. Appointment - Youth Council
Councilman McMillan presented Stephen Mawn's qualifications for ser-
vice as a member of the Larchmont-Mamaroneck Youth Council and on
motion by Councilman McMillan, seconded by Councilman Amlicke, it
-6-
1 ?9
was unanimously
RESOLVED, that Stephen Mawn of 74
Lansdowne Drive, Town, be and he hereby
is appointed a member of the Larchmont-
Mamaroneck Youth Council, effective
immediately.
5. JOINT PUBLIC HEARING:Draft Environmental Impact
Statement re Proposed Construction of Larchmont
Apartments
On motion by Councilman McMillan, seconded by Councilman Amlicke, it
was unanimously
RESOLVED, that the Public Hearing be
and it hereby is declared open.
The Town Clerk presented for the record the Affidavits of Publication
and Posting of the Notice of Hearing.
Deputy Supervisor Bloom explained the reason for this hearing and the
relevant laws; reviewed the history of the proposal; clarified the
decisions to be made by the Town Board, Planning Board and Zoning Board
and emphasized that no decisions will be made this evening since the
time for accepting comments has been extended to July 9th. He further
emphasized that this Board's responsibility is to decide after receiving
oral and written comments whether the proposal will have a significant
environmental impact and noted that such comments will now be heard on
the Draft Environmental Impact Statement. At this time Paul Kalos,
Chairman of the Town Planning Board reviewed the reason for this Board
being here this evening holding a public hearing in conjuction with the
Town Board but for a somewhat different, yet similar purpose.
Joel Sachs, Attorney for Garfield Housing Corporation addressed the Board
and also reviewed in detail the events leading up to this evening with
respect to the proposed apartment complex, including specific events
and dates.
George Forbes, Co-Counsel for Garfield Housing Corporation addressed
himself solely to the Planning Board, speaking in support of the applica-
tion for approval of the Subdivision.
Michael Weiner of the Planning Firm that prepared the Draft E.I.S.
highlighted some of the major aspects of that document and used visual
aids to clarify his presentation and described in detail all aspects
of the proposed building and its immediate surroundings. Mr. Weiner
also elaborated on the traffic study conducted by his firm in relation
to this proposal and other proposed developments being considered in
surrounding areas.
Steve Davis, who was responsible for the preparation of the air quality
and noise sections of the report, expounded on those subjects.
The matters of drainage, flooding, sanitary sewers, illegal connections
and water supply were elaborated on by John Meyer.
After Deputy Supervisor Bloom stated that all persons wishing to address
the Board should clearly state their name and address, noting that a
public stenographer was recording this Hearing, the following persons
addressed the Board on the topics that follow:
-7-
130
Gilda and Marshall Kaplan, 99 Madison Avenue, Town
Jerry and Maxine Sanders, 42 North Chatsworth Avenue, Town
Robert and Carol Dallos, 1 Huguenot Drive, Town
Morton and Adele Goldstein, 21 North Chatsworth Avenue, Town
Heidi Apt, 7 Lafayette Road, Town
Maria Russell, 18 Mountain Avenue, Town
Rosemarie and Carmine Magazino, 134 Murry Avenue, Town
Maxwell Barrett, 16 North Chatsworth Avenue, Town
Frances Miglio, 16 North Chatsworth Avenue, Town
Kathy Siconolfi, 51 North Chatsworth Avenue, Town
Dr. Leo Wilson, 15 Lafayette Road,Town
Leonard Martin, Larchmont Acres, Town
Barbara Klein, 16 Lafayette Road, Town
Patricia Latona, 8 Lafayette Road, Town
Horace Cardoza, 49 North Chatsworth Avenue, Town
Lilly Kadison, 1 Washington Square, Town
Robert Immerman, 47 Valley Road, Town
James Kerrigan, 3 Washington Square, Town
Dorothy Camilla, 1 Washington Square, Town
Evelyn Walker, 14 Lafayette Road
John Troy, 64 Pinebrook Drive, Larchmont Village
Ted Brown, 5 Lafayette Road, Town
Louise Sonnet, 17 Lafayette Road, Town
Lee Ryan, 1 Overlook Terrace, Town
Ellen Kahan, 21 North Chatsworth Avenue, Town
Rose Silva, 7 Normandy Road, Town
Howard Weinberg, 21 North Chatsworth Avenue, Town
Frank Connelly, Attorney, 249 Huguenot Street, New Rochelle
Arlene Adelman, 3 Washington Square, Town
Anthony Math, 1 Washington Square, Town
- purpose of the continuation of this Public Hearing on July 14th
due to urging that Hearing not be held during summer months and concern
that all residents wishing to have an opportunity to be heard on this
matter not be denied because of the lateness of the hour
- Irving Feder's connection with this project
- emphasis that noise, air quality, traffic and density will have
a significant adverse affect on the environment
- submission and presentation of prepared statements disputing conclu-
sions drawn in the Draft E.I.S.
- submission and presentation of a prepared statement describing the
distance problem of the proposed building from certain single-family
homes
- issue raised of inadequate fire re p rotectio
n for proposed building
- emphasis on impact on present recreational facilities
- emphasis on impact on visual effects with respect to altering
residents' existing views by removal of trees
- problem of displacement of wilflife (rodents, skunks and racoons,etc.)
- Alteration to the character of the neighborhood with respect to the
insensitivity of the proposed building in relation to compatibility of
the surrounding area
-8-
131
- traffic safety concerns with repsect to previous request for traffic
light in the area of North Chatsworth and Edgewood Avenue
- queries regarding change of configuration of surrounding streets in
relation to number of lanes
- increased impact on garbage collection; fire and police protection
- impact of eventuality of Thruway becoming a toll free road
- increased stop and go traffic, impacting on air pollution
- tax revenue to be derived from proposed development
- water condition - corner of Lafayette Road and Madison Avenue
- impact on already serious problem of parking
- references to 1966 Master Plan
- size of proposed project (5.5 acres vs 4.8 acres) and land coverage
by building
- aspects of retention basin on Madison Avenue
- concern about only one entrance and exit to and from proposed building
Member of the Planning Board, Mary Carlson noted that her Board has yet
to hear from the Conservation Advisory Commission in relation to this
project and since the Chairman, Alan Mason was in the audience, he stated
that comments will be received from his Commission before July 9th once
they have had an opportunity to meet and discuss the Statement.
At this time on motion by Councilwoman Silverstone, seconded by Council-
man Amlicke, it was unanimously
RESOLVED, that this Board hereby
adjourns this Joint Public Hearing
until July 14th.
ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business to come before this Board, on motion
duly made and seconded, this meeting was declared adjourned at 12:25 A.M.
on June 24, 1982.
Town Clerk
Dorothy S. Miller
-9-
132
MINUTES OF EXECUTIVE SESSION
JUNE 24, 1982
The Executive Session was called to order at 12:26 A.M. on
June 24, 1982 following the adjournment of the Special
Meeting.
Deputy Supervisor Bloom, Councilman Amlicke and Councilwoman
IllSilverstone were present as were Town Clerk, Dorothy Miller
and Town Attorney James Johnston.
The memoranda of the Town Engineer, Charles Elfreich and
Town Attorney, James Johnston relative to Marbourne Meadows
Subdivision litigation were reviewed with clarifications by
Mr. Johnston.
On motion by Councilman Amlicke, seconded by Councilwoman
Silverstone, it was unanimously
RESOLVED, that this Board hereby
authorizes the Town Attorney James J.
Johnston to proceed with the settle-
' ment of the Sachetti vs. Blair liti-
gation along the lines outlined in
his memorandum attached hereto.
Thereafter, on motion duly made and seconded, the executive
session was adjourned at 12:32 A.M.
Town Clerk
Dorothy S. Miller
li!I i
-10-
•
WESTCHESTER COUNTY. N. Y.
FOUNOEO 1661
TOWN ATTORNEY'S OFFICE
1889 PALMER AVENUE
LARCHMONT. N. Y. 10538
JAMES J. JOHNSTON
TOWN ATTORNE'Y 834-9444
TO: Deputy Supervisor. DATE: June 23, 1982
Members of the Town Council
RE: MARBOURNE MEADOWS SUBDIVISION
(U.S. COURT OF APPEALS - SECOND CIRCUIT)
•
Yesterday the Town Engineer and i appeared before Nathanial
Fensterstock, Staff Counsel, for a pre-argument conference
regarding the litigation entitled Sachetti v. Blair.
This has to do with the development of the property known
as the Marks property so as to accommodate 53 homes to be
built by Windsor Realty Corporation.
For several years, certain neighbors who feel that they will
•
• be detrimentally affected by a third road (which had been approved
by the Town Planning .Board) , have litigated before all of the
Courts of New York State and, on two occasions, the District
•
Court for the Southern District, their grievance.
Yesterday a rather new element surfaced when Mr. Mendelson,
a principle and attorney for all plaintiffs, argued that since
the Planning Board minutes did not set forth why they had'
allowed the developer to invoke Subsection M of Section 400
of the revised regulations for the approval of subdivision
plats in the Town of Mamaroneck, he was deprived of his
constitutional and civil rights in not being able to frame,
much less articulate an adequate petition before Special Term
in the New York Courts.
-Section M reads:
"Variations of the general requirements above
outlined may be permitted by the Planning Board
on application to the Planning Board when in its
judgment, special factors warrant such a
variation_ "
Subsection 3 of Section 277 of the Town Law states:
"Notwithstanding, the foregoing provisions of this
section, the planning board may waive, subject to
appropriate conditions, the provisions of any or all
of such improvements and requirements as in its
,
1 3 4 \
_ _ \
1 ,
■ -
MEMORANDUM: Deputy Supervisor
\ Town Council .
Ill June 23, 1982
1
Page 2
,
-....,-,
judgment all the special circumstances of a particular
i - 1 plat or plats are not requisite in the interest of the
public health, safety and general welfare, or which
in its judgment are inappropriate because of inadequacy
or lack of connecting facilities adjacent or in proximity
to the subdivision. "
The provisions of this Subsection were made part of the Town's
argument at all levels of litigation in this proceeding. The
1
Court at Special Term specifically mentioned that this Section
I
was a justification for the Planning Board's decision. - . .
In fairness to Mr. Mendelson, he has complained about the inade- _
quacies of the minutes at all levels of litigation. However, he
never argued until his appeal to the U.S. Courts that the inade-
qUacy was a deprivation of his Constitutional and Civil Rights.
Mr. Fensterstock drew our attention to a newspaper article
appearing on the front page of yesterday's New York Times. (A
-„,, copy of which is attached hereto and made a part hereof.) -
, . Mr. Fensterstock claimed that he thought that the case which was
11/
the basis of the article could have an affect on the Circuit
Court Judges and possibly this litigation if the provisions of
Section 1983 (Civil Rights Act of 1871) were to be enlarged again
by the Supreme Court.
,
. . .
i Both the attorney for, the developer and I took the position
1
that Judge Griesa of the District Court had overcome this argument
previously in stating that the present case is not brought under .
Section 1983, but directly under the Fifth and Fourteenth
1
Amendments. The Judge then ruled that since Mendelson's appeal
did not come within the provisions of Section 1983 that his claim
I
was barred. Fensterstock took the position yesterday that since
. 1
the Court was now employing Section 1983 in civil rights cases,
-Lich as the one reported in the proceeding entitled Patsy v.
Florida Board of Regents (#80-1874) , that it could conceivably
I
have meant to widen its provisions and interpretation to actions
Such as the one presently pending before the Circuit Court,
entitled Sachetti v. - Blair. While I feel that this is a rather
1
remote possibility and so advised Mr. Fensterstock, he said that
i
all parties should consider seriously an amicable disposition of
the case.
1 .
11/
-
- Fensterstock then asked Mendelson how the matter could be settled.
Mendelson said that he believed that his co-plaintiffs would agree
• to a row of tress or bushes being planted which would help to
prevent people coming from the property of the developer into
their backyards.
-- _ , --
1 -1_2- '
1.35
_
MEMORANDUM: Deputy Supervisor
Town Council
June 23, 1982
Page 3
For the amount of space involved (.approximately 500' ) our
Engineer estimated that it would cost about $1,500; Mr. Mendelson
figured $10,000. We did not disclose our Engineer's figure
to Mr. Fensterstock. I then said that if the hedges or tress
were to be planted, that they should be on the rear property of
the plaintiffs. Mr. Mendelson took exception to this, but
did agree that if the trees were to be put on Town land, that
he would have his co-plaintiffs sign an agreement obligating
them to the maintenance and care of whatever plantings were •
eventually put in. Mr. Feniterstock then asked when I could
put this proposition before the Town Board. I mentioned that
there was a special Board meeting this evening and that I
would attempt to have it before the members of the Board at
that time. Mr. Fensterstock then gave us until Friday to
r
advise the Court as to whether or not, this proposal would be
acceptable by all parties . At the same time, he, Mr. Fensterstock
Pointed out that he thought that the plantings would be
considerably less than the cost of printing the record on
appeal and the briefs, and suggested that this be brought to
the attention of our respective, clients.
•
The cost of the trees will be borne by the developer. As of
this writing, there has been no communication on the developer' s
side as to their receptivity to this proposal. However, their
attorney has indicated to me that he believes, that they will
accept this way of resolving the litigation and the attorney,
has additionally said that he will recommend this form of
settlement.
I, on behalf of the Town of Mamaroneck, also recommend this
ettlement. It will be of no cost to us; the maintenance,
.care and pruning of the screening to be planted will be borne
• by the owners of the property, and we will finally resolve the
Matter once and for all.
Chuck Elfreich, by separate coverrwill indicate the benefits he
can envision with the screening being planted on Town property.
I, therefore, respectfully request that I. be authorized to
settle this matter along the above set forth lines.
OW
•
41 James J. Johnston
Town Attorney
JJJ:jmm
Att.
-13-
1
I ,
') 136
TOWN OF MAMARONECK ---. .. I Maazriatoneck, N. Y.
•
To: .- Honorable Town Board Date: June 23, 1982
From: Charles R. Elfreich, Town Engineer
Subject: Marbourne Meadows Subdivision
IIII reviewed the construction plans for the above mentioned subdivision in
response to Mr. Mendelson's request for the planting of hemlock trees as a
buffer between the rear of their properties and the curbing of the proposed
road (Prince Willows Lane). My first reaction was that any plantings should
be on private property. However, if the plantings are spaced so close as to
• create a barrier, then I question how the grass on Town property will be.
maintained. Therefore, I recommend that any such plantings be installed as
close as possible to the curb's edge without reaching out over the paved way.
Each respective property owner should.be fully responsible for maintenance of
said trees.
For the frontage along Prince Willows Lane (460. feet) 5 foot high hemlocks
� planted .8 feet apart would require approximately 60 trees. An allowance of
$100 per tree furnished and installed totals $6,000.. Depending upon quality
and quantity this estimate could vary. There is a short section of drain
line in this area. It could be relocated to allow for the planting of trees.
1 Some of the area has rock out croppings. Those areas would have to be dealt
with separately.
1.
CRE:dm ,1 4,
1
,
•
. .
. -
-. .. . c V. • • "
-i4-